If you are searching for coins in Erie, estate sales, auctions, yard sales, and local flea markets can be some of the best places to discover silver coins, collectible currency, and hidden treasures at affordable prices.
If you enjoy the thrill of the hunt, few hobbies are as rewarding as searching for coins at estate sales and auctions around Erie. Hidden among boxes of collectibles and forgotten drawers, valuable coins, silver pieces, and even bullion regularly appear — often priced far below market value. Whether you are collecting for fun or planning to flip coins for profit, Erie offers plenty of opportunities for smart buyers.
Why Estate Sales Are Great for Coin Finds
Estate sales are one of the best places to discover coins because many sellers simply want to clear out items quickly. Families may not always know the true value of older coin collections, silver rounds, or proof sets. That creates opportunities for buyers willing to do a little research.
Auctions can also be productive, but it’s important to choose where you participate carefully. Online platforms sometimes look appealing, but not every experience is positive. For example, after trying to purchase coins through AuctionZip, I won several lots but never received the items. Thankfully no money was lost, but I never received the coins and the seller completely disappeared — a frustrating experience that made me move on from that platform quickly.
Where to Sell Coins After You Find Them
If your goal is flipping coins for profit, you have two strong options:
1. Local Private Sales
Selling locally allows you to avoid fees and shipping hassles. Listing coins on a private local marketplace gives buyers the chance to inspect items in person, which can build trust and speed up sales.
2. Large Online Auction Platforms
Sites like eBay offer access to a massive audience of collectors worldwide. While you may sometimes achieve higher prices online, you’ll need to factor in shipping, fees, and packaging time. That said, I have personally sold many silver coins and bullion on eBay without ever running into a problem. Considering the volume of transactions, that reliability has been impressive.
A Trusted Local Coin Shop in Erie
For those who prefer face-to-face transactions, one highly recommended stop is Dempsey & Baxter on Peach Street near the Millcreek Mall. Local shops like this can be excellent places to buy or sell coins safely. While you might occasionally receive slightly less than an online auction’s top price, you gain immediate payment, expert evaluation, and zero shipping risk — which many sellers find worthwhile.
Don’t Overlook Yard Sales in Erie
While estate sales and auctions are popular places to search, don’t forget that yard sales in and around Erie can also produce surprising coin finds. Many weekend garage sales, neighborhood yard sales, and community sales across Millcreek, Harborcreek, and Fairview occasionally include coin jars, old collections, or inherited silver coins that sellers simply want gone. Buyers searching Erie yard sales often discover wheat pennies, silver dimes, proof sets, and even small bullion pieces mixed in with everyday household items. If you regularly explore yard sales in Erie, PA, keep small bills handy and always ask if the seller has coins or collectibles not yet displayed — sometimes the best treasures never make it onto the table.
Check Local Flea Markets for Hidden Coin Deals
Local flea markets are another excellent place to hunt for coins, especially if you enjoy browsing multiple vendors in one stop. Coin jars, small collections, and silver pieces regularly appear at regional markets, often priced to sell. I have personally seen coins offered at the Waterford Flea Market as well as the Gem City Flea Market, which at the time of this writing is held once a month at the Harborcreek Moose Club. Flea markets give buyers the advantage of negotiating directly with sellers, and many vendors are open to bundle deals if you are purchasing multiple items.
Tips for Successful Coin Flipping
- Learn basic silver and coin values before buying
- Bring cash to estate sales and yard sales for better negotiating power
- Check condition carefully — scratches and cleaning can reduce value
- Research sold listings online to understand real market prices
- Build relationships with local sellers and dealers
Start Your Erie Coin Treasure Hunt
Coin hunting combines history, strategy, and excitement. One weekend you might walk away empty-handed, and the next you could discover a box of silver coins hiding in plain sight. That unpredictability is part of the fun.
If you uncover great coin finds around Erie, feel free to list them on Erie Marketplace and connect with local collectors who share the same passion. Good luck treasure hunting — your next great discovery could be waiting at the very next estate sale, yard sale, or flea market.
If you are interested in some current silver coin prices, I have curated a list of some of my favorite ones. I also list some of the highest priced coins so you can search for them while treasure hunting this year. My list can be found here: Silver Treasures
I am an eBay Partner and if you click the link above and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It helps me keep this website up and running.
