Erie is home to a thriving thrift and secondhand shopping scene, offering everything from vintage décor to budget‑friendly household goods. This directory highlights some of the top thrift stores in the area, making it easy to explore unique resale shops and discover hidden gems across the city. They are not ranked in any particular order and all of them have their own unique items.
Cobbs Second Time Around Thrift Shop- 1215 Parade Street Just south of 12th Street. They have a huge variety of previously loved items that you can make your own.
Goodwill has two locations: Their new store is on Buffalo Road by Burger King and across the street from Perkins Restaurant. Their bigger location is Goodwill Summit Center at 7200 Peach St, Erie, PA 16509
Salvation Army is at 12th and Sassafras. Their address is 1209 Sassafras and remember Salvation Army is closed on Sunday. Their second store is right by Lowe’s off of Peach Street. The address is 1944 Keystone Drive.
AMVETS Erie, located at 3424 Liberty Street in Erie, Pennsylvania, is a community‑focused thrift store offering a wide selection of gently used clothing, furniture, household goods, and more. When you shop here, you directly support military veterans, with proceeds helping AMVETS continue their mission of serving those who served our country.
Founded in 1911, Erie City Mission has long served as a cornerstone of support for people and families affected by addiction. Located at 1017 French Street in downtown Erie, the organization provides outreach, resources, and hope to those working to rebuild their lives and strengthen the community around them.
Thrifter Heaven Thrift Store, located at 4455 West Ridge Road in Erie, is operated entirely by dedicated volunteers who work to keep prices affordable while offering high‑quality secondhand finds. Shoppers can explore a wide variety of gently used clothing, home goods, décor, and unique thrift treasures. Every purchase helps support local individuals and agencies in need, along with charitable efforts that reach several countries around the world. It’s a spot where great deals and meaningful community impact come together.
Finders Keepers of Erie, located in Erie, PA, is a popular spot for anyone who loves discovering unique secondhand finds and affordable home décor. This locally loved consignment and resale shop features an ever‑changing mix of furniture, vintage pieces, household items, collectibles, and budget‑friendly thrift treasures. Whether you’re furnishing a room, hunting for one‑of‑a‑kind décor, or simply enjoy the excitement of thrift shopping, Finders Keepers offers a constantly refreshed selection that makes every visit feel like a new adventure. Stop in to explore a wide variety of quality resale items and uncover your next great find. Their address is 1250 Brown Avenue.
Mel and Tee’s Secondhand Thrift Store is a local treasure for anyone who loves hunting for unique resale items and affordable vintage finds. This Erie shop features an impressive mix of antiques, estate pieces, collectibles, furniture, die‑cast cars, and everyday household goods. Shoppers will also find a standout selection of Matchbox cars, Hot Wheels, sports cards, DVDs, sports memorabilia, jewelry, knick‑knacks, and a wide range of hand tools. For those who enjoy the metaphysical side of thrifting, the store also offers crystals and stones. With such a diverse and constantly changing inventory, Mel and Tee’s is a must‑visit destination for thrift lovers and bargain hunters looking for quality secondhand items. Their location is 4915 Hillsdale Avenue.
“Looking for more great deals? Check out my curated finds on eBay — supporting this site helps keep the Erie Marketplace growing.” Retired Jeff’s Great Deals
“Some links on this site may be affiliate links. As an eBay Partner, I may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through my curated deals.”
Do you like shopping Yard Sales? Check out my Erie Yard Sale page. It will also help you if you are planning a Yard Sale.
